The NSCA All- American Athlete of the Year Award program is over 30-years-old, and is made possible by a grant from Power Systems, Inc., a Knoxville, Tennessee fitness product leader.

2013
Cheldon Brown, MT&F
Carol Henney, VB
Emily Jacobson, WSOC
Chris Otule, MBB
Carlye Shug, WT&F

2012
Ciara Jones
Tyler O'Brien

2010
Lazar Hayward, MBB

2009
Jessica Keiser, VB
Paige Fiedorowicz, WBB
Erynn James, WT&F
Nick VanDeraa, MT&F
Wesley Matthews, MBB
Michelle Compty, WSOC

2008
Michelle Compty, WSOC
Jessica Keiser, VB
Wesley Matthews, MBB
Greg Sirotek, MTEN